Katelyn: Can you talk about the journey of playing the whole cycle? How are the works in dialogue with each other?
Jennifer: Everything is contextual, especially when I’m thinking about the larger shape of all six.
How I approach each one is slightly different.
First, you start at the G Minor Sonata. First Partita: B minor. Second Sonata: A minor. Second Partita: D minor. And then you start moving into major.
There's something significant about going through the first sonata, the first partita. Bach is writing within forms that existed before. You have the doubles [an ornamented variation of a dance movement, played immediately after the original dance], which are slightly different. Theoretically, people think that was supposed to be the repeat. But now it's traditionally played separately.
Then in the second sonata, you see a change: at the end of the first movement, he ends on the dominant, not the tonic. Then the fugue is 50% longer than the first sonata, so he's expanding what was there before. Then in the third movement, you have this eighth note, this pulsation that goes underneath the melody. For me, that feels like the first heartbeat of an artist coming into their own.
Then the second partita kind of blows that form out of the water. You have four movements which had existed before. However, 50% of it is the Chaconne, which is totally unlike anything that had been written before. This idea of questioning—which happened already at the end of the first movement of the second sonata, considering that he doesn't go back to tonic. But in the Chaconne, it's minor, major, minor—three huge sections.
There's something so amazing about the last note—D. Are we going back into the light, into major, or are we staying in minor? It becomes this question, this yearning. It's a question that I think stays in the listener's ear.
It's a choice. You've gone through this struggle. It's not about ignoring suffering, the difficult parts in your life. It's about having acknowledged those things, expressed those things, engaged with loss, and then deciding to move into major. That's just crazy remarkable to me.
Then you move into the first movement of the third sonata, C major. It goes into a 16th-note D—the same pitch. What's interesting to me is it relates to that third movement of the second sonata—this elongated, dotted eighth.
Then you have this massive intellectual crown, like he's building a cathedral through the fugue—a huge architectural masterpiece. It starts transforming into joy and happiness. So after you go through this whole lifetime, suddenly in the third to the fourth movement, you see this transformation to joy.
Then you go into the E Major Partita, which is the shortest of all of the sonatas and partitas. In some ways the most traditional. You think it's one thing—it's in major, it seems very straightforward—but it's actually something different. There's no doubles. It's all dance movements. So it's a return, looking backwards, but it changes the meaning of what joy is at the beginning of your life—like a baby laughing versus somebody who's lived through an entire lifetime and has come to the decision to embrace joy.
The context of where and how it's placed…it's amazing to me. It changes the meaning of the work, I think.
Katelyn: This program is close to three hours long. How do you build up the endurance for this performance, mentally and physically?
Jennifer: I really should be working out. I keep telling myself, you should work out today, Jenny. That hasn't happened. I will probably get to it and then be like, why didn't I start this six months earlier?
It is physically challenging. The biggest thing is a psychological, spiritual challenge. It's a kind of meditation—are you able to sustain that for several hours?
Then it's hard because you're so vulnerable. It's so exposed. When I'm doing it, I feel like I'm living in the world with no skin on—even on the street. As a New Yorker, you can't feel every single thing that somebody in one subway car is feeling. But for some reason, when I'm doing this, I become so much more sensitized to every interaction and every feeling that sometimes it feels almost painful to exist in the world. That sounds a little weird. But it's true.